Security Verification Checklist¶
Version: 1.0.0
Last Updated: January 15, 2026
Purpose: Verify security controls before production deployment
Overview¶
This checklist ensures all security controls are properly implemented and tested. Use this before: - Production deployments - Security audits - Compliance assessments - Release milestones
Status Legend: - ✅ Implemented and Tested - ⚠️ Implemented, Needs Verification - ❌ Not Implemented - 🔄 In Progress
1. Input Validation¶
1.1 Lexer & Parser¶
| Control | Status | Evidence | Notes |
|---|---|---|---|
| All input tokens validated | ✅ | src/lexer/mod.rs | E101-E199 errors |
| Grammar rules enforced | ✅ | src/parser/mod.rs | E201-E299 errors |
| Unicode handling secure | ✅ | tests/entity_parser_tests.rs | Homograph tests |
| Recursion bounded (max 100) | ✅ | src/parser/mod.rs | Stack overflow prevention |
| Input size limited (10MB) | ✅ | CLI args | --max-input-size |
| Error messages don't leak sensitive data | ✅ | src/error/mod.rs | Secret redaction |
| Fuzzing coverage >80% | ✅ | fuzz/parser_fuzzer | 500+ corpus |
Verification:
# Run parser tests
cargo test --test entity_parser_tests
# Run fuzzing (5 minutes)
cd fuzz && cargo +nightly fuzz run parser_fuzzer -- -max_total_time=300
1.2 Import Validation¶
| Control | Status | Evidence | Notes |
|---|---|---|---|
| Path traversal prevented | ✅ | src/semantic/import_checker.rs | E501 error |
| Circular imports detected | ✅ | Import graph analysis | E502 error |
| Namespace collision prevented | ✅ | Symbol table | E503 error |
| Trust policies enforced | ✅ | src/semantic/trust_checker.rs | E504 error |
| Layer boundaries respected | ✅ | src/semantic/layer_validator.rs | E601-E608 errors |
Verification:
2. Secret Management¶
2.1 Secret Flow Analysis¶
| Control | Status | Evidence | Notes |
|---|---|---|---|
| Secret types properly defined | ✅ | src/types/secret.rs | Secret<Hashed/Encrypted/Tokenized> |
| Secret-to-plain conversion forbidden | ✅ | src/semantic/secret_flow.rs | E402 error |
| Secret comparison forbidden | ✅ | src/semantic/secret_flow.rs | E403 error |
| Secrets excluded from logs | ✅ | Generated code | Automatic redaction |
| Secrets excluded from error messages | ✅ | src/error/mod.rs | E404 error |
| Secrets excluded from API responses | ✅ | src/codegen/openapi/mod.rs | Schema generation |
| No serialization of secrets | ✅ | Generated TypeScript | No JSON.stringify() |
| Flow analysis sound | ✅ | 15 test cases | tests/secret_flow_tests.rs |
Verification:
cargo test --test secret_flow_tests
cargo test --test week11_validation_tests -- --nocapture | grep -i secret
2.2 Secret Storage¶
| Control | Status | Evidence | Notes |
|---|---|---|---|
| Hashed secrets use bcrypt/argon2 | ✅ | Generated code | Min 10 rounds |
| Encrypted secrets use AES-256-GCM | ✅ | Generated code | NIST-approved |
| Tokenized secrets use secure tokens | ✅ | Generated code | 32+ bytes entropy |
| Keys stored in environment variables | ✅ | Deployment config | Never in code |
| Key rotation supported | ⚠️ | Manual process | Needs automation (v1.1) |
Verification:
# Check generated code for crypto usage
grep -r "bcrypt\|argon2\|aes-256-gcm" compiler/target/debug/generated/
3. Policy Enforcement¶
3.1 Compile-Time Checks¶
| Control | Status | Evidence | Notes |
|---|---|---|---|
| Behavior requires authorization | ✅ | src/semantic/policy_checker.rs | E301 error |
| Policy totality enforced | ✅ | src/proof/policy_totality.rs | E304 error |
| Policy expressions validated | ✅ | Semantic analyzer | Type checking |
| Tautology detection | ⚠️ | Basic checks only | Enhanced linting (v1.1) |
| Policy complexity warnings | ❌ | Not implemented | Future: v1.1 |
Verification:
cargo test --test policy_enforcement_tests
cargo test --test week11_validation_tests -- --nocapture | grep -i policy
3.2 Runtime Enforcement¶
| Control | Status | Evidence | Notes |
|---|---|---|---|
| Middleware validates authorization | ✅ | Generated TypeScript | JWT validation |
| Role-based access control (RBAC) | ✅ | Generated code | User roles checked |
| Policy re-checked at runtime | ✅ | Generated code | Defense in depth |
| Authentication required | ✅ | Generated middleware | JWT/session |
| Session management secure | ✅ | Generated code | HttpOnly, Secure flags |
| CSRF protection enabled | ✅ | Generated middleware | Token validation |
Verification:
cargo test --test week11_runtime_tests
# Inspect generated middleware
cat compiler/target/debug/generated/src/middleware/auth.ts
4. Escape Validation¶
| Control | Status | Evidence | Notes |
|---|---|---|---|
| Escape requires adapter | ✅ | src/semantic/escape_validator.rs | E902 error |
| Adapter registry validated | ✅ | Compile-time check | Missing adapters fail |
| Adapter types checked | ✅ | Type checker | Input/output types |
| Adapter isolation enforced | ⚠️ | Documentation only | Sandbox (v2.0) |
| Adapter usage logged | ✅ | Generated code | Audit trail |
Verification:
cargo test --test escape_validation_tests
# Try compiling example with missing adapter
cargo run -- examples/with_escape.usl
5. Generated Code Security¶
5.1 SQL Injection Prevention¶
| Control | Status | Evidence | Notes |
|---|---|---|---|
| All queries parameterized | ✅ | src/codegen/sql/ | No string concat |
| No dynamic table/column names | ✅ | Generated SQL | Schema-validated |
| Input validation in API layer | ✅ | Generated TypeScript | Zod schemas |
| ORM/query builder used | ✅ | Generated code | Kysely for type-safety |
| SQL injection tests pass | ✅ | 38 codegen tests | Injection attempts fail |
Verification:
cargo test --test week10_codegen_tests
# Inspect generated SQL
cat compiler/target/debug/generated/db/queries/*.sql
# Verify parameterization
grep -r "\\$[0-9]" compiler/target/debug/generated/db/queries/
5.2 XSS Prevention¶
| Control | Status | Evidence | Notes |
|---|---|---|---|
| API returns JSON (not HTML) | ✅ | Generated code | Content-Type: application/json |
| Content-Type headers set | ✅ | Generated middleware | Helmet.js |
| CSP headers configured | ✅ | Deployment config | Strict CSP |
| No eval() or Function() | ✅ | Generated code | Static analysis |
| User input never interpolated | ✅ | Generated code | Template parameters |
Verification:
# Check Content-Type headers
grep -r "Content-Type" compiler/target/debug/generated/src/
# Verify no eval/Function
grep -r "eval\|Function(" compiler/target/debug/generated/src/
5.3 Authentication & Authorization¶
| Control | Status | Evidence | Notes |
|---|---|---|---|
| JWT validation implemented | ✅ | Generated middleware | HS256/RS256 |
| Token expiration enforced | ✅ | Generated code | Configurable TTL |
| Refresh tokens supported | ✅ | Generated endpoints | Secure rotation |
| Password hashing secure | ✅ | bcrypt/argon2 | Min 10 rounds |
| Rate limiting configured | ⚠️ | Configurable | Not enabled by default |
| Brute-force protection | ⚠️ | Manual configuration | Needs default (v1.1) |
Verification:
cargo test --test week11_runtime_tests
# Check JWT validation
cat compiler/target/debug/generated/src/middleware/auth.ts
6. Layer Boundaries¶
| Control | Status | Evidence | Notes |
|---|---|---|---|
| Domain layer pure (no I/O) | ✅ | src/semantic/layer_validator.rs | E601 error |
| Service layer no direct DB access | ✅ | E602 error | Must use query layer |
| Query layer read-only | ✅ | E651 error | No writes |
| API layer validates input | ✅ | Generated code | Zod schemas |
| Cross-layer imports validated | ✅ | E606 error | Dependency graph |
Verification:
7. Deployment Security¶
7.1 TLS/HTTPS¶
| Control | Status | Evidence | Notes |
|---|---|---|---|
| TLS enforced in production | ✅ | Generated configs | Nginx/ingress |
| HSTS headers enabled | ✅ | Deployment manifests | max-age=31536000 |
| TLS 1.2+ required | ✅ | Nginx config | TLS 1.3 preferred |
| Strong cipher suites only | ✅ | Configuration | No weak ciphers |
| Certificate validation | ✅ | Generated code | No self-signed in prod |
Verification:
# Check deployment configs
cat compiler/target/debug/generated/deployment/nginx.conf
grep -i "ssl\|tls" compiler/target/debug/generated/deployment/*.yaml
7.2 Container Security¶
| Control | Status | Evidence | Notes |
|---|---|---|---|
| Non-root user in containers | ✅ | Generated Dockerfile | USER node |
| Minimal base images | ✅ | Alpine Linux | <100MB |
| No secrets in images | ✅ | .dockerignore | Env vars only |
| Image scanning enabled | ⚠️ | Manual | Trivy/Snyk recommended |
| Read-only root filesystem | ⚠️ | Configurable | Not default |
Verification:
# Check Dockerfile
cat templates/docker/Dockerfile
# Scan image
docker build -t usl-test .
trivy image usl-test
7.3 Kubernetes Security¶
| Control | Status | Evidence | Notes |
|---|---|---|---|
| Network policies defined | ✅ | Generated manifests | Ingress/egress rules |
| RBAC configured | ✅ | ServiceAccounts | Least privilege |
| Pod security policies | ✅ | Generated YAML | No privileged pods |
| Secrets managed externally | ✅ | Vault/sealed-secrets | Not in manifests |
| Resource limits set | ✅ | Generated YAML | CPU/memory limits |
Verification:
# Check Kubernetes manifests
cat compiler/target/debug/generated/deployment/k8s/*.yaml
kubectl apply --dry-run=client -f compiler/target/debug/generated/deployment/k8s/
8. Dependency Security¶
| Control | Status | Evidence | Notes |
|---|---|---|---|
| cargo audit passing | ✅ | CI/CD | No known vulnerabilities |
| cargo deny configured | ✅ | .cargo/deny.toml | License + advisories |
| cargo vet enabled | ⚠️ | Setup needed | Supply chain verification |
| Dependabot enabled | ✅ | GitHub | Weekly checks |
| Dependencies reviewed | ✅ | Manual review | Quarterly |
| Lockfile committed | ✅ | Cargo.lock | Reproducible builds |
Verification:
9. Testing & Fuzzing¶
9.1 Test Coverage¶
| Control | Status | Evidence | Notes |
|---|---|---|---|
| 232 integration tests pass | ✅ | CI/CD | 100% passing |
| Security-specific tests | ✅ | 50+ tests | Secrets, policies, layers |
| Code coverage >80% | ✅ | tarpaulin | ~82% overall |
| Edge cases tested | ✅ | Property testing | Proptest |
| Regression tests | ✅ | CI/CD | All issues have tests |
Verification:
9.2 Fuzzing¶
| Control | Status | Evidence | Notes |
|---|---|---|---|
| Parser fuzzing enabled | ✅ | fuzz/parser_fuzzer | 500+ corpus |
| Semantic fuzzing enabled | ✅ | fuzz/semantic_fuzzer | 300+ corpus |
| Proof fuzzing enabled | ✅ | fuzz/proof_fuzzer | 200+ corpus |
| Codegen fuzzing enabled | ✅ | fuzz/codegen_fuzzer | 150+ corpus |
| Nightly fuzzing runs | ✅ | CI/CD | 30 minutes per target |
| Fuzzing coverage >85% | ✅ | Metrics | libFuzzer stats |
Verification:
cd fuzz
cargo +nightly fuzz run parser_fuzzer -- -max_total_time=300
cargo +nightly fuzz run semantic_fuzzer -- -max_total_time=300
cargo +nightly fuzz run proof_fuzzer -- -max_total_time=300
cargo +nightly fuzz run codegen_fuzzer -- -max_total_time=300
10. Documentation & Compliance¶
| Control | Status | Evidence | Notes |
|---|---|---|---|
| Security documentation complete | ✅ | docs/security/ | 7 documents |
| Threat model documented | ✅ | threat-model.md | 15 threats identified |
| Vulnerability disclosure policy | ✅ | vulnerability-disclosure.md | Public |
| Security checklist available | ✅ | This document | Used before releases |
| Audit preparation guide | ✅ | audit-prep.md | Ready for auditors |
| Compliance documentation | ✅ | compliance.md | GDPR, HIPAA, PCI-DSS |
| Security roadmap published | ✅ | README.md | v1.1, v1.2, v2.0 |
Verification:
Pre-Production Deployment Checklist¶
Before deploying to production, verify:
Critical (Must Fix)¶
- All tests passing (232/232)
- No cargo audit vulnerabilities
- No secrets in code/configs
- TLS enabled and enforced
- Authentication configured
- Authorization policies tested
- Secrets properly encrypted
- Database backups configured
- Monitoring and alerting enabled
- Incident response plan documented
High Priority (Should Fix)¶
- Rate limiting configured
- Brute-force protection enabled
- Key rotation process documented
- Container images scanned
- Kubernetes RBAC configured
- Network policies applied
- Log aggregation configured
- Security headers validated
Medium Priority (Nice to Have)¶
- cargo vet configured
- Read-only root filesystem
- Pod security policies strict
- DDoS protection configured
- Web application firewall (WAF)
- Security training completed
- Penetration testing performed
- Third-party audit completed
Automated Verification¶
Run the complete security verification suite:
# Run all security checks
./scripts/security-audit.sh
# Expected output:
# ✅ cargo audit: 0 vulnerabilities
# ✅ cargo deny: 0 advisories
# ✅ cargo test: 232/232 passing
# ✅ Fuzzing: No crashes
# ✅ Secret scan: No secrets in code
# ✅ Generated code: No vulnerabilities
Continuous Monitoring¶
Daily¶
- Review authentication failures
- Monitor API error rates
- Check resource usage (DoS detection)
- Review security logs
Weekly¶
- Run cargo audit
- Review Dependabot PRs
- Check for new CVEs
- Review access logs
Monthly¶
- Review security metrics
- Update threat model
- Test incident response
- Security training
Quarterly¶
- Dependency review and updates
- Security documentation review
- Penetration testing
- External security audit
Sign-Off¶
Before production deployment, obtain sign-off:
| Role | Name | Date | Signature |
|---|---|---|---|
| Security Lead | |||
| DevOps Lead | |||
| Engineering Manager | |||
| CTO/VP Engineering |
Version History¶
- v1.0.0 (2026-01-15): Initial checklist
- Document updated with each release
For questions, contact: security@usl-lang.org